| 2024 Q : Wilson (Henryetta) over Frontier 65-50 |
| 2019 Q : Cyril over Frontier 78-48 |
| 2018 Q : Frontier over Southwest Covenant 74-66 |
| 2018 S : Frontier over Rattan 65-63 |
| 2018 C : Fort Cobb-Broxton over Frontier 62-50 |
| 2017 Q : Regent Prep over Frontier 31-28 |
| 2008 Q : Frontier over Rattan 63-46 |
| 2008 S : Thomas over Frontier 40-36 |
| 2007 Q : Frontier over Pioneer-Pleasant Vale 60-58 |
| 2007 S : Beaver over Frontier 54-49 |
| 2006 Q : Frontier over Pioneer-Pleasant Vale 85-77 |
| 2006 S : Frontier over Thomas 42-41 |
| 2006 C : Frontier over Roff 55-48 |
| 2005 Q : Frontier over Varnum 60-54 |
| 2005 S : Frontier over Macomb 73-46 |
| 2005 C : Frontier over Beaver 56-49 |
| 2004 Q : Frontier over Morrison 70-54 |
| 2004 S : Frontier over Fort Cobb-Broxton 58-51 |
| 2004 C : Frontier over Roff 89-56 |
| 2003 Q : Frontier over Sentinel 72-51 |
| 2003 S : Frontier over Ripley 72-55 |
| 2003 C : Coyle over Frontier 71-69 |
| 2002 Q : Frontier over Wright City 60-56 |
| 2002 S : Laverne over Frontier 55-49 |
| 2001 Q : Cimarron over Frontier 56-52 |
| 2000 Q : Frontier over Forgan 70-64 |
| 2000 S : Frontier over Chattanooga 62-48 |
| 2000 C : Boynton over Frontier 80-76 |
| 1999 Q : Frontier over Keyes 87-68 |
| 1999 S : Frontier over Boynton 68-67 |
| 1999 C : Frontier over Forgan 61-47 |
| 1998 Q : Frontier over Okay 88-69 |
| 1998 S : Vanoss over Frontier 60-56 |
| 1997 Q : Frontier over Preston 87-72 |
| 1997 S : Frontier over Alex 69-54 |
| 1997 C : Frontier over Okarche 56-46 |
| 1996 Q : Frontier over Ripley 60-37 |
| 1996 S : Frontier over Cashion 81-56 |
| 1996 C : Frontier over Ketchum 77-55 |
| 1995 Q : Frontier over Kiowa 80-76 |
| 1995 S : Hooker over Frontier 82-75 |
| 1992 Q : Grant over Frontier 73-70 |